The Old Fashioned

Why is it called an Old Fashioned? Who invented it? What actually goes in one? The answers start with a lost election in 1806.

The bar bill

The first cocktail recipe was printed as a joke. About buying votes.

Candidates used to buy votes with drinks. At the left of this painting, a voter gets his glass filled.

May 1806, Hudson, New York. A candidate loses, and the town paper prints his bar tab as a joke.

  • 720rum grogs
  • 411glasses of bitters
  • 32gin slings
  • 17brandies
  • 25cock-tails

Nothing

He won nothing. Now look at the last line of the tab.

“I have heard of a jorum, of phlegm-cutter and fog driver … but never in my life … did I hear of cock tail before.”

A Subscriber

This reader knew plenty of drink slang, but not this word. He asked the editor what a cock-tail was.

The editor answered with a recipe of four ingredients. Pick the four.

  • Spirits
  • Ice
  • Lemon juice
  • Sugar
  • An egg
  • Wine
  • Mint
  • Water
  • Honey
  • Soda water
  • Bitters
  • A cherry

Spirits (any strong liquor), sugar, water and bitters (alcohol soaked with bitter herbs). It had no ice, fruit or juice.

“Cock tail, then, is a stimulating liquor, composed of spirits of any kind, sugar, water, and bitters.”

The oldest definition of a cocktail ever found

Nobody knows who mixed the first one. This is the first time anyone wrote down what was in it.

The editor

Harry Croswell

27 years old in 1806. Pictured in old age.

  • His paperThe Balance, in Hudson, New York.
  • His habitAttacking politicians. An attack on President Jefferson in his other paper, The Wasp, got him convicted of libel.
  • Why he mattersHis answer to one confused reader is the oldest cocktail recipe on record.
“… a person having swallowed a glass of it, is ready to swallow any thing else.”

“Swallow” also means “believe”. Croswell’s joke: a voter full of cocktails will believe any candidate.

The oldest cocktail recipe is the setup for a political joke.

Sugar, bitters, a splash of water and the spirit, which today is whiskey. Two things here are newer than 1806 and get their own chapters: the ice and the name.

Spirits, sugar, water and bitters. In print since 1806.

The ice

In 1806 a drink with ice in it barely existed. A 22-year-old changed that.

No freezers in 1806. If you wanted ice, someone sawed it out of a pond. This 1919 film shows the same work, still done by hand.

The merchant

Frederic Tudor

22 years old in 1806. Painted about 1830.

  • Who he wasA rich Boston family’s son, with a pond on the family land.
  • His ideaCut pond ice in winter. Sell it where water never freezes.
  • Why he mattersHe started the trade that put ice in American drinks.

February 1806: Tudor shipped a brig full of pond ice to Martinique, in the Caribbean. The island had no icehouse, so he sold it off the ship as it melted.

Tudor kept at it. In 1833 his ice left Boston for Calcutta: 16,000 miles, four months, two crossings of the equator.

180 tons went into the hold. How much was still ice in India?

About 100 tons, kept frozen under sawdust. Within three days Calcutta was planning an icehouse.

Tudor also had to make people want ice. His salesmen gave it to bartenders free and taught them to make cold drinks.

Tudor, who had once been jailed for his debts, was now called the Ice King.

Ice chills the drink. As it melts, it adds a little more water.

The bitters

The bitters in your drink began as stomach medicine for an army.

This is Angostura, the bitters most bars use. Bitters are strong alcohol soaked with bitter herbs and spices. A few dashes season a drink the way salt seasons food.

The doctor

Johann Siegert

A German army doctor

  • Where he wentVenezuela, 1820, as chief surgeon to Simón Bolívar’s army in its war against Spain.
  • What he madeA stomach tonic for soldiers, finished in 1824 in the town of Angostura. The bitters are named for the town.
  • Why he mattersThat tonic is the bitters in an Old Fashioned today.

Bitters season the drink. The best-known brand began as an army doctor’s tonic.

The barman

For 56 years no bartender put the recipe in a book. Then one did.

One barman got famous in the 1850s for a trick like this: burning whiskey, poured in a stream. He called his the Blue Blazer.

This is Jerry Thomas pouring a Blue Blazer: whiskey and boiling water, set alight and thrown from mug to mug.

The barman

Jerry Thomas

Born in 1830 in Sackets Harbor, New York

  • Before the barAt 18 he sailed to California for the gold rush.
  • By 1858He ran the bar at New York’s Metropolitan Hotel and was the best-known bartender in America.
  • Why he mattersIn 1862 he published the first bartender’s guide.

The first bartender’s guide ever published

How to Mix Drinks, published in New York in 1862.

“3 or 4 dashes of gum syrup. 2 do. bitters (Bogart’s). 1 wine-glass of whiskey, and a piece of lemon peel. Fill one-third full of fine ice.”

Sugar, bitters and spirit, as in 1806, now with whiskey and ice. “Do.” means ditto.

The 1806 recipe took any spirit, and early cocktails used brandy or gin just as often. Whiskey won because America made it.

In 1862 the cocktail entered the first bartender’s guide, with whiskey and ice.

The name

Bartenders kept adding liqueurs to the cocktail. To get the plain one, you had to ask for it “old-fashioned”.

By the 1870s bartenders were dressing the cocktail up with sweet liqueurs. The best bars had come to look like palaces.

“Prepared in the same manner as the Improved Brandy Cocktail, by substituting Bourbon or rye whiskey for the brandy.”

Jerry Thomas’s guide added “Improved” cocktails in 1876. The extras were cherry liqueur and absinthe, a strong spirit that tastes of anise.

Drinkers who hated the extras asked for an “old-fashioned” cocktail. The Chicago Tribune printed the phrase in 1880.

“Dissolve a small lump of sugar with a little water … add two dashes Angostura bitters, a small piece ice, a piece lemon-peel, one jigger whiskey.”

By 1895 bar guides printed the order as its own recipe. The four highlights are the 1806 recipe. Ice and peel are the additions.

“Old-fashioned” was how drinkers ordered the original cocktail.

The myth

A Louisville club gets the credit for this drink. The dates say otherwise.

You may hear the drink was invented here, at the Pendennis Club in Louisville, for a bourbon maker named James Pepper. The story comes from a 1931 book.

The name was in print by 1880. Guess the year the Pendennis Club was founded.

1881. The name was in print a year before the club existed.

Who invented it? Four suspects.

  • A Louisville club bartender1880sThe story: he mixed it at the Pendennis Club for the bourbon maker James Pepper, who carried it to New York.Too late: in print by 1880
  • Jerry Thomas1862He printed the Whiskey Cocktail in the first bartender’s guide.Recorded it 56 years on
  • Theodore Proulx1888A Chicago bartender. His manual has the first recipe printed under the name Old-Fashioned.Named it. Already ordered
  • Nobody on recordbefore 1806Spirits, sugar, water and bitters was already a known drink when the Hudson editor defined it.The best answer

The drink and its name are both older than the club.

The comeback

For decades this drink came buried in mashed fruit. Then bartenders dug it out.

In 1900 Carrie Nation began smashing saloons to protest alcohol. Edison’s company filmed this comedy about it.

In 1920 the United States banned alcohol. Prohibition lasted until 1933. Here, agents pour a barrel into a New York sewer.

After Prohibition the drink came with fruit mashed into it. Some say the fruit first hid bad liquor.

Bartenders went back to old guides like Jerry Thomas’s and took the fruit out. A strip of orange peel stayed.

The Old Fashioned held number one for seven years. In 2022 the Negroni, a gin drink, passed it.

Bartenders took the mashed fruit back out around 2000.

Your turn

You know the story. Now make one: six ingredients, eight moves.

Know your bottles.

  • BourbonAmerican, mostly corn. Sweeter.
  • RyeAmerican, mostly rye grain. Drier, spicier.
  • ScotchScottish malt, often smoky. Rare in this drink.
  • BrandyMade from wine, not grain. Wisconsin’s pick.

Make one.

Sugar, bitters, water, ice, whiskey, peel. That follows the International Bartenders Association recipe, which also adds a cherry.

An Old Fashioned is spirit, sugar and bitters over ice. Which of these is one?

  • Tequila, orange liqueur, lime juice
  • Rye whiskey, sweet vermouth (a wine), bitters
  • Tequila, mezcal, agave syrup (a sweetener), bitters

The third, an Oaxaca Old Fashioned, sweetened with agave. The first is a Margarita, which adds lime juice. The second is a Manhattan, which swaps the sugar for vermouth.

Three common questions.

  • Bourbon or rye?Either works. Bourbon is sweeter, rye is drier.
  • Sugar cube or syrup?Either. Syrup mixes faster.
  • Fruit?A strip of orange peel. No mashed fruit.

The Old Fashioned is the oldest cocktail recipe on record. It got its name when drinkers had to ask for it the old way.

Before you go: the order.

Your turnOrder one this week, or make the one you just built. Count six things going in: the four from 1806, plus ice and peel.

The official recipeInternational Bartenders Association→